- "Andrew Garland is a star singer beginning to burst forth. I am his devoted fan and supporter." — Marilyn Horne
- "Excellent acting and singing chops." — Seattle Opera, La Boheme
- "Commanding intensity." — The New York Times
- "Projected energy, optimism and a focussed baritone." — Cincinnati Opera, Galileo
- "Astonishing." — Opera News
- "The standout among the vocal soloists. The unshakeable power and dark color of his voice were ideal. " — The Boston Globe